Bargain or value trap? Fundie rates 3 ASX 200 shares going for cheap

Ask A Fund Manager

The Motley Fool chats with the best in the industry so that you can get an insight into how the professionals think. In this edition, Chester Asset Management portfolio manager Rob Tucker decides whether three heavily discounted ASX shares are value traps or bargains.

Bargain buy or value trap?

The Motley Fool: Let’s examine three S&P/ASX 200 Index (ASX: XJO) shares that have been devastated this year, and see if you think each of these fallen stars are now a bargain to pick up or if you’d stay away. The first one is Life360 Inc (ASX: 360), a software stock that’s plunged almost 30% since November.

Rob Tucker: Yeah, Life360 is a really interesting company. We use it in our family. I’m well aware of the business model and I think it will ultimately be successful. 

We probably have more of a value bend, so it’s probably not one for us just yet. But listening to the company on a webcast yesterday, I’ve followed very closely, if they can say what they’re going to do, which is [to] become cash flow breakeven this year, I’d look a lot closer at it.  If I was thinking interest rates were going to be cut, and these tech companies would have another leg to their story, Life360 would certainly be one I’d be interested in.

I’d really prefer to see it get to cash flow breakeven before I entertained it. I do like it. I think it’s a very strong story.

MF: You’re the first person I’ve run into who’s actually used the software. How do you find it? You obviously find it useful.

RT: Yeah, we’ve got [from] a nine-year-old to a 15-year-old — four kids. And we find it very useful just tracking them. I don’t need to ring them.

I say, “My son’s at the park having a kick of footy.” You can see, “Oh, he’s at 7-Eleven.” I quite like it for that reason.  There’s about 34 million users, with about one-and-a-half [million] paid subscribers. The Life360 story’s actually converting those users into paid subscribers. 

And they’ve got a bit of a pricing lever.  Most of the time in the US, it’s for crash protection and some driving awareness software in terms of alerting if they’ve had a crash, they can alert the insurance company and get the ambulance sent out and things like that. A lot of people in America use it for that reason. 

If they can convince people that there’s real value-add services in all the products they have, and the number of paid subscribers keeps growing, I think it will be a genuinely strong cash flow story. I’d like to see a little bit more, just another year or so of momentum before we entertain it. MF: Fair enough.

Next one’s Corporate Travel Management Ltd (ASX: CTD), which is down about a third since April. RT: Corporate Travel’s not one I spent that much time on personally. I’m obviously familiar with the business model, but not that close to the management team.

I’ll make a broad comment that I think corporate travel is being priced for an acceleration of travel expenditure, and that’s [why] I’m probably quite cautious over the next 12 months.  I think we’ve had a honeymoon [period] of revenge spending on travel in the backend of 2022. Everyone wanted to get away and booked travel. 

I think we’re going into a period of economic weakness… It is cyclical, and I think we’ve had a huge uptick, and I think [travel] probably softens off a bit over the next 12 to 18 months. I think for me, Corporate Travel’s still probably on the sidelines just because of the cyclical softness we’ll see in the next 12 to 18 months in travel spend.

MF: The last one is Insignia Financial Ltd (ASX: IFL), which used to be IOOF. That’s still 62% lower than pre-COVID highs. Bargain or value trap?

RT: We think that’s a really strong leverage to rising markets. It’s unbelievably cheap. It may be a value trap, but I think you’re, with a 7.5% dividend yield, being paid to wait for an uptick in the market. 

It’s a really high fixed cost base, so if the market does participate and funds under management rises, the fall through the bottom line will accelerate earnings aggressively. I think it’s really interesting here. I’d say it’s probably one we’d look at.

We don’t hold it, but it’s one that we’d look at quite closely.

I’m more on the buy side.

Of those three, for me, it’d probably be IFL, 360 with a little bit more cash flow certainty, and then Corporate Travel.

Tags:

jo-malone-london listed on couponmatrix.uklenovo listed on couponmatrix.ukmagazines-direct listed on couponmatrix.ukmillennium-hotels listed on couponmatrix.ukoutdoor-and-country listed on couponmatrix.ukparadise-wildlife-park listed on couponmatrix.uk
jo-malone-london listed on couponmatrix.ukThose looking to expand their sensory horizons won’t find more opulent scents to sample than at Jo Malone London. A leading provider of perfumes for over 30 years, Jo Malone has refined smells for hundreds of happy customers. Take the leap and discover a fragrance you never knew you needed for less with a Jo Malone discount code from Groupon, then you’ll have both the scent and the savings for whatever your weekend brings you.
lenovo listed on couponmatrix.ukLenovo was founded in 1984 by a group of ten engineers in Beijing and has grown from humble beginnings to become a world leader in computer technology. In 2013, Lenovo was revealed to be the world’s largest personal computer vendor by unit sales and operates in more than 60 countries. Shoppers can check here for a Lenovo discount code to be used on a wide range of products, from smart televisions to IT management software.
magazines-direct listed on couponmatrix.ukWho said print media is dying? At Magazines Direct, you’ll find plenty of life in old-school printed magazine subscriptions, with publications covering everything from gardening, fashion, motorbikes, wine, celebrity gossip, and so much more! Pick up your Magazines Direct discount code and enjoy some fantastic savings on your favourite magazines, delivered to your door every month. With so much choice, you’ll never miss out on the latest news in all your favourite industries thanks to Magazines Direct!
millennium-hotels listed on couponmatrix.ukMillennium have around 120 hotels covering five continents, offering premium level accommodation, top-class business and leisure facilities and a vast selection of restaurants to suit all tastes and most budgets. Their reputation means you're assured a warm welcome from them no matter how tiring your journey is or how chaotic things are out on the street. The Millennium Hotel discount code serves as your perfect travel partner, ensuring value for money and valuable savings that you can spend on meals and treats instead.
outdoor-and-country listed on couponmatrix.ukOutdoor and Country is the home of the best British brands such as Barbour and Fairfax, alongside innovative international labels. Whether you’re a city slicker or a country dweller, the Outdoor and Country collection blends contemporary flair with timeless tradition. Explore enduring styles for men, women, and children meticulously crafted for outdoor adventures. Elevate your outdoor wardrobe with an exclusive Outdoor and Country discount code from Groupon, with the added perks of free delivery on orders over £35 and free returns.
paradise-wildlife-park listed on couponmatrix.ukHertfordshire’s hidden gem has won multiple awards for its enclosures and conservation initiatives, and the big cats, primates and endless other species that are lucky enough to have this extraordinary facility as their home will be delighted to meet you. Your Paradise Wildlife Park vouchers won’t just enable you to meet the residents, though - there are many other attractions on offer, including a dinosaur park to keep the roar factor on eleven even when the lions are taking lunch.