Why do pharmaceutical companies give away some expensive …

This is just one of the stories from our “I’ve Always Wondered” series, where we tackle all of your questions about the world of business, no matter how big or small. Ever wondered if recycling is worth it? Or how store brands stack up against name brands?

Check out more from the series here.


Listener Mattan Schuchman from Baltimore asked:  Why do pharmaceutical companies charge exorbitant rates for their products but then give them away for free or virtually no cost to most patients, regardless of income, through patient assistance programs? Is this something that they do to get a tax write-off for a charitable contribution?

This is particularly common among “specialty drugs” like those used to treat multiple sclerosis. A prescription for Mayzent, a drug used to treat multiple sclerosis, can cost upwards of nearly £10,000. But a financial assistance program offered by the drug’s manufacturer might mean you don’t have to pay any co-pay at all. Patient assistance programs help provide patients with drugs for free or at a lower cost than they normally would have to pay.

These programs were in the spotlight recently after Moderna faced pressure for saying it would raise the price of its COVID-19 vaccine. The pharmaceutical giant is expected to raise the price of its vaccine from £26 per dose to between £110 and £130, but said it would still be available for free for many patients through a patient assistance program. However, Vermont Sen.

Bernie Sanders has criticized these programs, calling them “poorly designed” and “extremely difficult, if not impossible, for patients to access.”  Health experts say that while patient assistance programs can provide financial relief for patients on an individual level, they actually drive up premium prices, leading to higher prices for all of us.

How patient assistance programs work 

Some pharmaceutical companies have their own patient assistance programs, while others are offered by independent charities that are funded by the pharmaceutical industry.  Although companies might invest in free drug programs that are geared toward the uninsured, funds primarily go to assistance programs that provide coverage for those who already have health insurance, said Stacie Dusetzina, a professor at Vanderbilt University Medical Center.

“So companies basically will create a situation where they can lower the price to the patient, but charge as much as they want to the health insurance plan that is covering that patient,” Dusetzina said. “So it seems like a really charitable thing to be doing. But it also creates a setup where companies can raise their prices pretty substantially.” Dusetzina said Medicare prohibits people from using coupons, so instead, Medicare beneficiaries can get support through a foundation or charity.

“That allows them to pay their co-pays, or whatever part the patient owes. And then the health plan pays the rest of that usually very large bill,” Dusetzina said. “It is often a means to basically ensure that people fill these drugs, and most of those payments are being made by the health insurance company rather than by the patient or by the manufacturer.”  Ariadne Fugh-Berman, a pharmacology and physiology professor at Georgetown University Medical Center, said these programs are a way for pharmaceutical companies to deflect attention from high drug prices and bolster their reputation.

“They really will do anything to avoid government regulation of drug prices,” Fugh-Berman said. “They want to give the impression that they are doing something about it.”  The Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health released a study back in 2019 on independent charity prescription drug assistance programs, finding that nearly all failed to offer coverage for those without insurance.  These programs offered varying forms of support.

Some offered co-payment assistance, while others offered the choice of helping with co-pays or insurance premiums. Eligibility requirements entailed a combination of having health insurance, a prescription for the drug being covered and proof of income.  Gerard Anderson, a health policy and management professor at Johns Hopkins University who co-authored the 2019 study on charity drug programs, noted that sometimes companies will give away drugs for free entirely, and aren’t merely providing assistance.

Anderson said there are various reasons for this: the drug might not cost a lot to make in the first place, it’s an opportunity for a pharmaceutical representative to make a new product pitch to a patient, or they get at tax write-off thanks to the donation. “Depending on how much they say the drug is worth, it can actually be worthwhile for them to have a bigger tax deduction than it costs them to produce the drug,” Anderson said. 

The problem with assistance programs

Part of the reason why economists dislike assistance programs is because your health insurance is supposed to guide you toward the drug that’s the best deal for them, Dusetzina explained. But if our health insurance system has to end up paying exorbitant prices for drugs, that puts pressure on it to raise the price that all patients pay for their insurance policies. 

While patient assistance programs and coupons are technically different, the issues with coupons highlight some of the problems with discounts.  Say there’s a cheaper generic drug available to you and the more expensive brand-name drug. Your health plan will want you to get the generic drug, since it’s cheaper overall.

But a pharmaceutical company might offer you a coupon, making the brand-name drug cheaper for you as an individual. But it’s still expensive for health insurers, Dusetzina explained.  “Coupons are really problematic, because [they] doesn’t allow insurers to kind of steer you to the drug that’s the best deal for them,” Dusetzina said. 

Anderson also said coupons could lead to higher premiums. Let’s say a drug company wants to charge £100,000 for a drug. You might have to pay £10,000, but if you get a coupon, you might not have to pay anything.

But the drug company will still end up making a lot of money.  “They haven’t gotten their £10,000. But they’ve gotten £90,000 from the insurance company,” he said.

So in that case, he added, nothing is stopping them from raising the price to £110,000 or even £150,000.  Anderson said that trying to reform these programs would be challenging. “We haven’t figured out a way to do so. Some people have said that we should just ban them, but you’re essentially taking a free good away from somebody who’s sick,” he noted. 

To tamp down on prices, Fugh-Berman said she would like to see federal legislation addressing this issue. As of right now, Medicare cannot negotiate prices with manufacturers.  “We’re not allowed to negotiate drug prices, and we have the highest drug prices in the world.

Who knew?” she said. 

Stories You Might Like

There’s a lot happening in the world.  Through it all, Marketplace is here for you.  You rely on Marketplace to break down the world’s events and tell you how it affects you in a fact-based, approachable way. We rely on your financial support to keep making that possible. 

Your donation today powers the independent journalism that you rely on. For just £5/month, you can help sustain Marketplace so we can keep reporting on the things that matter to you.  

blurb listed on couponmatrix.ukbook-my-garage listed on couponmatrix.ukcartridge-shop listed on couponmatrix.ukdaysoutcom listed on couponmatrix.ukeureka-the-national-children-s-museum listed on couponmatrix.ukmiss-selfridge listed on couponmatrix.uk
blurb listed on couponmatrix.ukAre you a budding writer, design professional or photographer looking to show off your work? Take publishing into your own hands with online platform Blurb and you could create your own e-book, photo album or magazine with ease. Cut the costs of your project with a Blurb discount code from us and turn your creative ideas into professional-quality publications, printing as many copies as you choose.
book-my-garage listed on couponmatrix.ukWhen your vehicle next needs a tune-up, always go through Book My Garage to get the best price possible. A space that allows you to compare and pick between dozens of local garages near you, it’s as cost-effective as it is convenient when there's a Book My Garage promo code to use with your booking. From the smallest filter change to a comprehensive service of your vehicle, find all you need to drive with ease at Book My Garage.
cartridge-shop listed on couponmatrix.ukHaving over 20 years’ experience in supplying printers, ink, toner, paper and more for customers worldwide, Cartridge Shop knows better than most how to get the perfect print without breaking the bank. As a bastion for printing supplies, accessories, stationery and plenty else besides, you’ll be how astonished the amount you can save with a Cartridge Shop discount code at your side. So whether you work from home or are looking to refill the office printer, Cartridge Shop is your one and only choice for quick and convenient service.
daysoutcom listed on couponmatrix.ukHalf-term adventures, unforgettable dates and city staycations start with a visit to daysout.com, where you can find things to do anywhere in the UK. Whether it’ll be London, Birmingham or Edinburgh on the cards, make it a day to remember with affordable tickets for you and the family – our Days Out discount codes can save you money at with Madame Tussauds, the London Dungeon, SEA Life Birmingham, the Magical London Pass and much more. From theme parks and zoos to historical attractions and interactive experiences, there’s no better place than daysout.com for heaps of inspiration and tips for a cheap day out.
eureka-the-national-children-s-museum listed on couponmatrix.ukLearn and play with the interactive Eureka! Museum, designed for children from 0-11. Eureka understand that kids learn best when having fun, that’s why this museum is not hidden by glass windows, but jam-packed with play-based learning activities to inspire curiosity, intellect, creativity and emotional development. With the Eureka discount code you can enjoy learning for less. Based in Halifax, Eureka! Offers a truly magical and unforgettable experience. There are hundreds of activities and events year-round, so treat your kid to a learning masterclass today.
miss-selfridge listed on couponmatrix.ukThe younger sister of high-end department store Selfridges has been outfitting the nation in youthful fashion in the latest designs since the 60s - the first line of clothing was, in fact, a range of paper dresses designed to be worn once and then thrown away. Since then, the store has introduced lines of jeans, shoes, and accessories to name but a few, and manages over 170 shopfronts in the UK alone. Use a Miss Selfridge discount code to get money off your next order of partywear, loungewear, or back to basics separates and you’ll be catwalk ready on the cheap, whatever your day holds for you. Miss Selfridge is now a part of ASOS, so you can shop all your fave Miss Selfridge styles over on the ASOS website.